Do not return default for comparisons between same types.

This commit is contained in:
Stephen Chung 2021-02-25 10:59:11 +08:00
parent 02057ef1d2
commit 49e5382ab0
3 changed files with 80 additions and 45 deletions

View File

@ -14,6 +14,7 @@ Breaking changes
* For plugin functions, constants passed to methods (i.e. `&mut` parameter) now raise an error unless the functions are marked with `#[rhai_fn(pure)]`.
* Visibility (i.e. `pub` or not) for generated _plugin_ modules now follow the visibility of the underlying module.
* Comparison operators between the sames types now throw errors when they're not defined instead of returning the default. Only comparing between _different_ types will return the default.
* Default stack-overflow and top-level expression nesting limits for release builds are lowered to 64 from 128.
New features

View File

@ -21,7 +21,6 @@ use crate::stdlib::{
string::ToString,
vec::Vec,
};
use crate::token::is_assignment_operator;
use crate::utils::combine_hashes;
use crate::{
calc_native_fn_hash, calc_script_fn_hash, Dynamic, Engine, EvalAltResult, FnPtr,
@ -174,6 +173,7 @@ impl Engine {
hash_fn: NonZeroU64,
args: &mut FnCallArgs,
is_ref: bool,
is_op_assignment: bool,
pos: Position,
) -> Result<(Dynamic, bool), Box<EvalAltResult>> {
self.inc_operations(state, pos)?;
@ -286,16 +286,17 @@ impl Engine {
// See if it is built in.
if args.len() == 2 && !args[0].is_variant() && !args[1].is_variant() {
if is_assignment_operator(fn_name) {
if is_ref {
// Op-assignment
// Op-assignment?
if is_op_assignment {
if !is_ref {
unreachable!("op-assignments must have ref argument");
}
let (first, second) = args.split_first_mut().unwrap();
match run_builtin_op_assignment(fn_name, first, second[0])? {
Some(_) => return Ok((Dynamic::UNIT, false)),
None => (),
}
}
} else {
match run_builtin_binary_op(fn_name, args[0], args[1])? {
Some(v) => return Ok((v, false)),
@ -756,12 +757,14 @@ impl Engine {
Ok((result, false))
} else {
// Native function call
self.call_native_fn(mods, state, lib, fn_name, hash_fn, args, is_ref, pos)
self.call_native_fn(
mods, state, lib, fn_name, hash_fn, args, is_ref, false, pos,
)
}
}
// Native function call
_ => self.call_native_fn(mods, state, lib, fn_name, hash_fn, args, is_ref, pos),
_ => self.call_native_fn(mods, state, lib, fn_name, hash_fn, args, is_ref, false, pos),
}
}
@ -1368,17 +1371,29 @@ pub fn run_builtin_binary_op(
x: &Dynamic,
y: &Dynamic,
) -> Result<Option<Dynamic>, Box<EvalAltResult>> {
let first_type = x.type_id();
let second_type = y.type_id();
let type1 = x.type_id();
let type2 = y.type_id();
let type_id = (first_type, second_type);
if x.is_variant() || y.is_variant() {
// One of the operands is a custom type, so it is never built-in
return Ok(match op {
"!=" if type1 != type2 => Some(Dynamic::TRUE),
"==" | ">" | ">=" | "<" | "<=" if type1 != type2 => Some(Dynamic::FALSE),
_ => None,
});
}
let types_pair = (type1, type2);
#[cfg(not(feature = "no_float"))]
if let Some((x, y)) = if type_id == (TypeId::of::<FLOAT>(), TypeId::of::<FLOAT>()) {
if let Some((x, y)) = if types_pair == (TypeId::of::<FLOAT>(), TypeId::of::<FLOAT>()) {
// FLOAT op FLOAT
Some((x.clone().cast::<FLOAT>(), y.clone().cast::<FLOAT>()))
} else if type_id == (TypeId::of::<FLOAT>(), TypeId::of::<INT>()) {
} else if types_pair == (TypeId::of::<FLOAT>(), TypeId::of::<INT>()) {
// FLOAT op INT
Some((x.clone().cast::<FLOAT>(), y.clone().cast::<INT>() as FLOAT))
} else if type_id == (TypeId::of::<INT>(), TypeId::of::<FLOAT>()) {
} else if types_pair == (TypeId::of::<INT>(), TypeId::of::<FLOAT>()) {
// INT op FLOAT
Some((x.clone().cast::<INT>() as FLOAT, y.clone().cast::<FLOAT>()))
} else {
None
@ -1402,16 +1417,19 @@ pub fn run_builtin_binary_op(
#[cfg(feature = "decimal")]
if let Some((x, y)) = if type_id == (TypeId::of::<Decimal>(), TypeId::of::<Decimal>()) {
// Decimal op Decimal
Some((
*x.read_lock::<Decimal>().unwrap(),
*y.read_lock::<Decimal>().unwrap(),
))
} else if type_id == (TypeId::of::<Decimal>(), TypeId::of::<INT>()) {
// Decimal op INT
Some((
*x.read_lock::<Decimal>().unwrap(),
y.clone().cast::<INT>().into(),
))
} else if type_id == (TypeId::of::<INT>(), TypeId::of::<Decimal>()) {
// INT op Decimal
Some((
x.clone().cast::<INT>().into(),
*y.read_lock::<Decimal>().unwrap(),
@ -1452,8 +1470,9 @@ pub fn run_builtin_binary_op(
}
}
if second_type != first_type {
if type_id == (TypeId::of::<char>(), TypeId::of::<ImmutableString>()) {
if type2 != type1 {
// char op string
if types_pair == (TypeId::of::<char>(), TypeId::of::<ImmutableString>()) {
let x = x.clone().cast::<char>();
let y = &*y.read_lock::<ImmutableString>().unwrap();
@ -1462,8 +1481,8 @@ pub fn run_builtin_binary_op(
_ => return Ok(None),
}
}
if type_id == (TypeId::of::<ImmutableString>(), TypeId::of::<char>()) {
// string op char
if types_pair == (TypeId::of::<ImmutableString>(), TypeId::of::<char>()) {
let x = &*x.read_lock::<ImmutableString>().unwrap();
let y = y.clone().cast::<char>();
@ -1472,7 +1491,7 @@ pub fn run_builtin_binary_op(
_ => return Ok(None),
}
}
// Default comparison operators for different types
return Ok(match op {
"!=" => Some(Dynamic::TRUE),
"==" | ">" | ">=" | "<" | "<=" => Some(Dynamic::FALSE),
@ -1480,7 +1499,9 @@ pub fn run_builtin_binary_op(
});
}
if first_type == TypeId::of::<INT>() {
// Beyond here, type1 == type2
if type1 == TypeId::of::<INT>() {
let x = x.clone().cast::<INT>();
let y = y.clone().cast::<INT>();
@ -1526,7 +1547,7 @@ pub fn run_builtin_binary_op(
}
}
if first_type == TypeId::of::<bool>() {
if type1 == TypeId::of::<bool>() {
let x = x.clone().cast::<bool>();
let y = y.clone().cast::<bool>();
@ -1540,7 +1561,7 @@ pub fn run_builtin_binary_op(
}
}
if first_type == TypeId::of::<ImmutableString>() {
if type1 == TypeId::of::<ImmutableString>() {
let x = &*x.read_lock::<ImmutableString>().unwrap();
let y = &*y.read_lock::<ImmutableString>().unwrap();
@ -1556,7 +1577,7 @@ pub fn run_builtin_binary_op(
}
}
if first_type == TypeId::of::<char>() {
if type1 == TypeId::of::<char>() {
let x = x.clone().cast::<char>();
let y = y.clone().cast::<char>();
@ -1572,7 +1593,7 @@ pub fn run_builtin_binary_op(
}
}
if first_type == TypeId::of::<()>() {
if type1 == TypeId::of::<()>() {
match op {
"==" => return Ok(Some(true.into())),
"!=" | ">" | ">=" | "<" | "<=" => return Ok(Some(false.into())),
@ -1580,11 +1601,7 @@ pub fn run_builtin_binary_op(
}
}
Ok(match op {
"!=" => Some(Dynamic::TRUE),
"==" | ">" | ">=" | "<" | "<=" => Some(Dynamic::FALSE),
_ => None,
})
Ok(None)
}
/// Build in common operator assignment implementations to avoid the cost of calling a registered function.
@ -1593,16 +1610,18 @@ pub fn run_builtin_op_assignment(
x: &mut Dynamic,
y: &Dynamic,
) -> Result<Option<()>, Box<EvalAltResult>> {
let first_type = x.type_id();
let second_type = y.type_id();
let type1 = x.type_id();
let type2 = y.type_id();
let type_id = (first_type, second_type);
let types_pair = (type1, type2);
#[cfg(not(feature = "no_float"))]
if let Some((mut x, y)) = if type_id == (TypeId::of::<FLOAT>(), TypeId::of::<FLOAT>()) {
if let Some((mut x, y)) = if types_pair == (TypeId::of::<FLOAT>(), TypeId::of::<FLOAT>()) {
// FLOAT op= FLOAT
let y = y.clone().cast::<FLOAT>();
Some((x.write_lock::<FLOAT>().unwrap(), y))
} else if type_id == (TypeId::of::<FLOAT>(), TypeId::of::<INT>()) {
} else if types_pair == (TypeId::of::<FLOAT>(), TypeId::of::<INT>()) {
// FLOAT op= INT
let y = y.clone().cast::<INT>() as FLOAT;
Some((x.write_lock::<FLOAT>().unwrap(), y))
} else {
@ -1621,9 +1640,11 @@ pub fn run_builtin_op_assignment(
#[cfg(feature = "decimal")]
if let Some((mut x, y)) = if type_id == (TypeId::of::<Decimal>(), TypeId::of::<Decimal>()) {
// Decimal op= Decimal
let y = *y.read_lock::<Decimal>().unwrap();
Some((x.write_lock::<Decimal>().unwrap(), y))
} else if type_id == (TypeId::of::<Decimal>(), TypeId::of::<INT>()) {
// Decimal op= INT
let y = y.clone().cast::<INT>().into();
Some((x.write_lock::<Decimal>().unwrap(), y))
} else {
@ -1652,8 +1673,8 @@ pub fn run_builtin_op_assignment(
}
}
if second_type != first_type {
if type_id == (TypeId::of::<ImmutableString>(), TypeId::of::<char>()) {
if type2 != type1 {
if types_pair == (TypeId::of::<ImmutableString>(), TypeId::of::<char>()) {
let y = y.read_lock::<char>().unwrap().deref().clone();
let mut x = x.write_lock::<ImmutableString>().unwrap();
@ -1666,7 +1687,9 @@ pub fn run_builtin_op_assignment(
return Ok(None);
}
if first_type == TypeId::of::<INT>() {
// Beyond here, type1 == type2
if type1 == TypeId::of::<INT>() {
let y = y.clone().cast::<INT>();
let mut x = x.write_lock::<INT>().unwrap();
@ -1706,7 +1729,7 @@ pub fn run_builtin_op_assignment(
}
}
if first_type == TypeId::of::<bool>() {
if type1 == TypeId::of::<bool>() {
let y = y.clone().cast::<bool>();
let mut x = x.write_lock::<bool>().unwrap();
@ -1717,7 +1740,7 @@ pub fn run_builtin_op_assignment(
}
}
if first_type == TypeId::of::<char>() {
if type1 == TypeId::of::<char>() {
let y = y.read_lock::<char>().unwrap().deref().clone();
let mut x = x.write_lock::<Dynamic>().unwrap();
@ -1727,7 +1750,7 @@ pub fn run_builtin_op_assignment(
}
}
if first_type == TypeId::of::<ImmutableString>() {
if type1 == TypeId::of::<ImmutableString>() {
let y = y.read_lock::<ImmutableString>().unwrap().deref().clone();
let mut x = x.write_lock::<ImmutableString>().unwrap();

View File

@ -12,7 +12,7 @@ fn test_mismatched_op() {
#[test]
#[cfg(not(feature = "no_object"))]
fn test_mismatched_op_custom_type() {
fn test_mismatched_op_custom_type() -> Result<(), Box<EvalAltResult>> {
#[derive(Debug, Clone)]
struct TestStruct {
x: INT,
@ -30,9 +30,18 @@ fn test_mismatched_op_custom_type() {
.register_type_with_name::<TestStruct>("TestStruct")
.register_fn("new_ts", TestStruct::new);
assert!(matches!(*engine.eval::<bool>(r"
let x = new_ts();
let y = new_ts();
x == y
").expect_err("should error"),
EvalAltResult::ErrorFunctionNotFound(f, _) if f == "== (TestStruct, TestStruct)"));
assert!(!engine.eval::<bool>("new_ts() == 42")?);
assert!(matches!(
*engine.eval::<INT>("60 + new_ts()").expect_err("should error"),
EvalAltResult::ErrorFunctionNotFound(err, _) if err == format!("+ ({}, TestStruct)", std::any::type_name::<INT>())
EvalAltResult::ErrorFunctionNotFound(f, _) if f == format!("+ ({}, TestStruct)", std::any::type_name::<INT>())
));
assert!(matches!(
@ -40,4 +49,6 @@ fn test_mismatched_op_custom_type() {
EvalAltResult::ErrorMismatchOutputType(need, actual, _)
if need == "TestStruct" && actual == std::any::type_name::<INT>()
));
Ok(())
}